20 min / beginner / 5 steps
Write a Performance Review in 20 Minutes
Paste your messy notes about a team member. Walk away with a structured, balanced, specific review ready to submit.
Performance reviews are painful because they require translating months of memory into structured written feedback, fairly, specifically, and constructively. Most managers either write something vague ("great collaborator!") or spend two hours agonising over phrasing. Claude handles the structure. You provide the truth.
follow along in
You need: A Claude account. Open claude.ai in a browser, or the Claude desktop app.
step 01 / 05
Give Claude the context
Start by telling Claude who you're reviewing, what level they are, and what dimensions matter. The more specific, the more useful the output.
PromptPaste into ClaudeI need to write an annual performance review for a direct report. Can you help me structure this?what you should see
Give Claude the contextmy-projectShareDescribe a task or ask a question+Accept editsstep 02 / 05
Paste your raw observations
Don't filter yourself here. Paste messy notes, bullet points, Slack messages, whatever you have. Claude will synthesise it.
PromptPaste into ClaudeHer name is Priya, Senior PM. Strong: led the onboarding redesign, 40% improvement in activation, shipped on time. Weak: changed requirements late in sprints twice without using change control. Engineering flagged it. She's technically strong but needs to grow as a collaborator with engineering.what you should see
Paste your raw observationsmy-projectShareDescribe a task or ask a question+Accept editsstep 03 / 05
Generate the structured draft
Claude writes the full review: overall summary, per-dimension ratings and commentary, and a forward-looking closing.
PromptPaste into ClaudeDraft the full review.what you should see
Generate the structured draftmy-projectShareDescribe a task or ask a question+Accept editsstep 04 / 05
Sharpen with specifics
Generic feedback feels unfair. Ask Claude to strengthen any section with more concrete language tied to real outcomes.
PromptPaste into ClaudeThe Impact section is good but make it more narrative. I want leadership to understand why this was hard, not just that the outcome was good.what you should see
Sharpen with specificsmy-projectShareDescribe a task or ask a question+Accept editsstep 05 / 05
Calibrate the tone
Ask Claude to adjust the balance. Softer for a fragile conversation, more direct for a high performer who needs honest feedback to grow.
PromptPaste into ClaudeThe collaboration section feels too harsh given how strong the rest of the review is. She's a high performer overall. I want the tone to reflect that while still being honest about the growth area.what you should see
Calibrate the tonemy-projectShareDescribe a task or ask a question+Accept edits
Tell someone what you built
Just finished "Write a Performance Review in 20 Minutes" on Claude Code Guide. Took about 20 min, and it's free: https://claudecodeguide.dev/tutorials/performance-review
New guides, when they ship
One email, roughly weekly. CLAUDE.md templates, workflows I actually use, and the cut-for-length stuff that does not make the public guides. One-click unsubscribe.
Or read Product Field Notes, the Substack
